A tragic mix-up between Yashasvi Jaiswal and Shubman Gill cost Jaiswal his double century in Delhi, sparking debate among fans and experts.


Cricket can be cruel at times when everything appears to be happening good and yashasvi jaiswal experienced it very firsthand on saturday morning in delhi. The left-handed batsman was batting like a dream, scoring an unbeaten 173 in the second Test against the West Indies. Everyone was waiting for his double century, which seemed almost certain. Then, suddenly, he was run out.
Then, in the second over of the day, Jaiswal drove Jayden Seales to mid-off for a quick single. Shubman Gill offered no reply at the other end. It was perhaps that he had uttered no in a too low voice, or perhaps that he had stopped; in any case he wavered a moment, and that moment was sufficient. Tagenarine Chanderpaul touched the ball, threw it to wicketkeeper Tevin Imlach, and the bails fell. Jaiswal was out for 175. A run-out that seemed incredibly difficult to prevent, and in cricket, it happens before you can even breathe.
The moment illuminated commentary boxes and social media simultaneously. Anil Kumble, the former India captain was straight to the point, when questioned about who was in the wrong. During the lunch break, he appeared on Star Sports and said it was clearly Jaiswal’s mistake. “The ball went to mid-off and there were no runs,” Kumble said. There was also another occasion when he surprised that the umpire did not consult the third umpire on whether the keeper had the full control before knocking off the stumps. He added, “It’s all worth investigating, but the decision itself was wrong.” According to Kotler, Jaiswal should have been more patient in the initial overs, when the bowlers are fresh and the fielders are alert.
Kumble also discussed the mindset of Jaiswal. He believed this child brought the same aggressive nature as the child from the previous night. “He was written up yesterday morning, but today he is a continuation of last night,” Kumble said. Experienced players always caution youngsters that the first few overs of a new day are always tough, even if the score is 170 runs.
Former West Indies opener Darren Ganga believed both were equally culpable. On air, he said, As a batter, once you have drawn a ball And struck one, You think you can make it. “That was Jaiswal’s situation. However, watching the replay, it was fifty-fifty. Gill was not quick enough in his hesitation to make it any better. He said this caused Gill to take two steps forward and stop midway – and that half a second was enough to cost him.
Subsequently, former India batting coach Sanjay Bangar followed suit and he did not spare Gill either. When the striker appeals, the non-striker must reply, Bangar said, Jaiswal was already committed; Gill should have trusted him. Once he stopped, that was it.” Every coach says this—when you call one coach, you have to drive both. There are no half-measures.
Jaiswal appeared frustrated and dealt with the event in a mature manner later. In the post-match interview he described it as a horrible mix-up. Even smiling he said, It happens sometimes. That Jaiswal, who was calm and polite, you could read the disappointment in him then. Everything, his timing, his position, had been close to perfect. And to sink down to that kind of a thing– it is the type of a rejection that lingers with you days.
In retrospect, it was just a miscommunication involving two players who generally understand each other. Jaiswal acted on instinct, Gill was safe. The decisions of these two were incompatible half a second, and that was all. The little conversation surrounding should the umpire have looked after the ball control or not, is immaterial; the dismissal seemed clean anyway.
Eventually, the irony will be the thing that will remain. It took a confused young batter to lose his wicket on something so simple. Nevertheless, 175 in a Test is something to be proud of. Gill atoned himself in a hundred or so, and retained India miles behind. The two will continue, but this confusion will linger in highlight reels a bit. Cricket is that stuff of yours, a single ball, a single call, and a single second late at times.
India vs West Indies Full Scorecard Link